Brutal force on a Peaceful Community
Church Backs off, disregarding the plight of villagers
Newspaper reports indicate that the church has backed off from the agitation against the dumping ground at Uttan. it is so strange that this has been allowed to be open, despite widespread protests and health hazards.
What about the people who got injured during their rightful and peaceful protest, what about all those who have come into the police records and arrested for protesting
Raymond Baptist Borges, Avita Walter Mendonca, Marie Peter Mendonca, Morris Valerian Nunes, Albert Rocky Mendonca, Jerome Peter Borges,Kaitan Anthon Gracious, Francis Kaitan Correa, Janet Nicklav Darius, Malisha Henry Patil, Margaret Joseph Correa, Priya Nazareth Gracious, Sunita Angel Mendonca,Rex Walter Gracious, Ruby Walter Gracious, Flory Charlie Almeida, Monica Joaquim Patil, Sweety David Correa, Angela Augustine Nunes, Ruksana Edward Nunes, Venita Francis Almeida, Georgie Malekar, Melvin Elias Colaso, Darius Joseph Patil, Gladys Joseph Kharjia, Sweety Joseph Patil
Similarly the four who were ordered not to enter Thane (Rural) for a period of two months
1. B. G. Kolse-Patil (Former Justice-Bombay High Court)
2. Nicholas Almeida (Sahar Citizens' Forum)
3. Vilas Sonawane
4. Shashi Sonawane
However their order got a stay in the High Court.
This was not over for them that the issued show cause notices to the following as to why they should not be externed for a period of two years from Thane, Mumbai, Pune, Nasik and Raigad.
1. Roney Corriea (Vice President-Civic and Political Cell)
2. James Colaso (Secretary-Civic and Political Cell)
3. Sunny Gadekar(Vice Secretary-Civic and Political Cell)
The hearing was given, however the order is still not passed.
Peaceful protest...false accusations
Newspapers have made a false claim that the protectors turned violent, their version is often the "official version" the facts however are quite different.
Please check the video for yourself to be well informed.http://uttandumpinggroundprotest.blogspot.com/
Police Assault on peaceful protest
WE CONDEMN POLICE ASSAULT ON PEACEFUL PROTESTERS.
The situation at Dongri village near Bhayander took an ugly
turn as police lathi charged and fired tear gas shells on protesters who were
engaged in a peaceful dharna to stop the garbage recycling plant that is set up
on a hill and has caused turmoil to the surrounding villages because of the
stench that it emanates.
The villagers who had kept vigil on the road to stop the
garbage trucks from reaching the garbage plant since the last twelve days were
subjected to a brutal lathi charge by the police when they tried to stop the
trucks by lying on the road. Immediately church bells were rung and thousands
of villagers poured on the streets. Fifteen activists were arrested and twenty admitted
in Bhagwati Hospital at Borivili for treatment of
injuries. Even women and children were not spared and many received head
Retired High Court Judge BG Kolse Patil who had given a call
to the locals to resort to dharna and keep 24 hour vigil to stop the menace at
a mammoth rally on 13th Sept 2009 at Kaka Baptista Chowk on Gorai Rd
rushed to the site but was stopped at village Dongri where he has resorted to
dharna on the road.
The Bombay Catholic Sabha condemns the ruthless manner in
which the police have behaved to stop peaceful protesters. The perpetrators of
this violence should be booked and suspended immediately. The garbage disposal
plant strangely set up on top of the hill has led to pollution of well water,
contamination of fields where cultivation is in progress and an unmistakable
stench that is noticed in the neighbouring villages depending on the direction
of the wind. The garbage recycling plant has taken away their right for clean
air, uncontaminated food and a healthy life. This is an assault on their
fundamental rights for a peaceful existence.
Perhaps the High Court has not taken this into consideration
when it asked the Government to use the help of police to clear the garbage
accumulated in the Mira Bhayander Municipal Corporation. But should the
wellbeing of some be at a cost of misery to others. The city fathers and the
administration have messed up the project by choosing this location. On no count should the villagers be
made to suffer for their folly.
It is unfortunate that 17000 signatures of protests were not
heeded, nor did the pollution control board take action when it was approached.
The undersigned corroborates this report after undertaking a fact finding
mission that consisted of a visit to the plant and a detour of the villages and
participating in the protest rally against the nuisance.
We demand that -
1. The so-called solid waste management project (Hanjar Biotech pvt. Ltd.,) of
the Mira-Bhayander Municipal Corporation should be completely stopped, scrapped
and shifted permanently from the Uttan Dhavagi hill top.
2. All the activists (about 15-16) should be immediately released
3. The officers who lathi charged and fired teargas on the innocent and
peaceful women, children and agitators should be suspended immediately and a
judicial enquiry should be appointed on the same
The Bombay Catholic Sabha and Spotlight is with the villagers in this hour
of crises. We wish them courage to carry on with the agitation till the
authorities decide to shift the recycling plant.
Vice President The Bombay
Editor - Christian Spotlight - The Community Journal
Editor - Spotlight - The Community Website
DUMPING GROUNDS AT DHAVGI HILL IN UTAN
Early morning, Sunday September 13th,
the Spotlight Team descended upon Utan to witness and observe the day
long dharna organized by the Civic and Political Cell of Mira Bhyander
Deanery, in association with at least fourteen social organizations
which included the National Association of Fishermen, The Bombay
Catholic Sabha, the Bombay East Indian Association, Justice & Peace
Commission, Gaothan Voice, Vasai Sangarsh Samiti, Center for Human
Ecology, just to name a few.
Utan, Palkhadi, Talavli, Anandnagar, Dongri, Tarodi, Pali, Chowk, and
Morva are protesting the unberable stench and havoc caused by the operators of the massive dumping grounds sitting atop the Dhavgi Hill right in the center of the nine villages. This
dumping ground is set up on Collectors land which was recently
transferred to the Mira Bhyander Nagarpalika who in turn has leased it
for a period of 30 years to a private business operator who runs a
garbage disposal company named Hanjer Biotech Private Limited.
visited the Dumping Grounds around 9.00 am to take stock of the
activities and goings on. We met up with the site supervisor Chetanbhai
to find out about how the garbage and waste is managed. The
site supervisor was reluctant to speak but we persuaded him to put us
in contact with the owners. He put us thru the cellphone with
Naseembhai Furniturewalla who with his brother Irfan Furniturewalla run
this garbage disposal company. During our conversations
we learnt that this dumping ground receives about 350 tons of Garbage
from the entire Mira Bhyander Municipal area. Residents of Utan feel this figure is fictitious considering the vast operating areas of the MBMC. They reckon it must be close to 800 or 1000 tons of garbage being dumped daily. We were also informed that the company segregates the waste and is able to process organic manure. From the sand and mud they are able to manufacture fuel bricks. Inert waste, they inform is dumped and they didnt say where. When we questioned them about the biohazardous and toxic waste, they seemed to be unaware of such quality of waste. When
we continued to enquire further, Chetanbhai left the room, sat on his
mobike and sped away leaving us alone in the office. There appeared to
be around 100 workers working on the site in most unhygienic conditions
There were no safety precautions, no masks, no headgear, no gloves, no
safety footwear. There was no evidence of workers using H2s
monitors to check out on the deadly gas as well as Norm Meters to
identify Normally Occuring Radioactive Materials. We were informed that the factory had a colony on the premises where these hapless migrant workers reside. The stench at the site was unbearable to us and probably the workers were by now immune to this. The place was seething with flies and crawly creepy insects. From
the hill and towards the village of Utan Pali one could easily see how
the polluted effluents had trickled onto the fields which stood barren
at this time of the year when sheaves of corn should be sprouting from
the paddy fields. This dumping ground has been in operation for
approximately 2-1/2 years now and caused innumerable health problems to
the lives of residents of villages around. Miya Saeed
Shah a vada paw vendor and resident of Motagao Utan stated that the
stench is unbearable in the mornings and children are falling sick and
the dispensaries and chemist shops in and around are making a killing . He says this dumping ground must be moved away, but the big question is How. Theres
been crores of rupees spent on the project and good money exchanged
between bureaucrats. It is reported that the Pollution Control Board of
Maharashtra has issued a notice to Hanjer Biotech Pvt.Ltd and
thereafter turned a blind eye. Another resident Dsouza uncle states
that this dumping ground is a trick played by the government. The proposed SEZ could not hatao the people of Dharavi Bet so they have now resorted to another angle. Cause
people fall sick, pollute the waters so people will be harassed into
moving out as they did during the great plague of the late 1800s.
Local leaders James Colaco and Sunny Gadekar played anchor at the dharna, which continued throughout the day. No dump trucks or any other vehicles were allowed to pass through and, a Total Rasta Roko was enforced, from dawn to dusk. However, sick patients were allowed to pass, duly escorted by volunteers. A number of speakers kept the 4000 plus sea of humanity spellbound and listening attentively. Vilas
Sonawne of the Yuva Bharat Sangathana in his own inimitable style poked
fun at the MMBC administration. He compared this dumping ground project
as the eight wonder of the world. A dumping ground sitting atop a hill like a flower plot whose fragrance spreads to the nine villages all around it. He
jokingly tried to educate people to keep their garbage bins in their
homes on the kitchen platform or dining tables instead of below the
kitchen at ground level. Prominent among the speakers were retired high court judge Kolse Patil and Fr. Alwyn Dsilva the dean of Mira Bhyander. There were a number of Priests and religious attending the dharna. This was complimented by a large contingent of police force with also a Fire Brigade in attendance. Fr.Victor
Dalmet, famous for his performances at various East Indian Singing
competitions composed and sang a song about this beautiful virgin
Dhavgi hill being molested and disfigured.